Conscious Beyond the Brain: The Role of the Autonomic Nervous System in Non-ordinary States of Consciousness

Abstract:

Non-ordinary states of consciousness (NOSCs), whether entered via psychedelics, breathwork, or other means, represent profound alterations in perception, emotion, and cognition. While research has largely focused on the cortical dynamics underpinning such shifts in consciousness, empirical evidence on the role of the autonomic nervous system (ANS) in NOSCs has remained observational. As a result, the potential contribution of the ANS to the phenomenological dimensions of NOSCs remains under-explored. Beyond simply regulating bodily functions, the ANS mediates processes directly linked to the core effects of many NOSCs, from emotional regulation to interoception and cognitive function.

Here, we propose a mechanistic framework by which the ANS may shape NOSCs. Integrating historical perspectives on neurophenomenology with current empirical evidence, this framework posits that bidirectional feedback loops between central and autonomic pathways enable deviations from autonomic homeostasis to spark altered information processing and adaptive neural reorganization. We explore two variations of this scenario based on differing levels of empirical support: (1) autonomic state functions as a contextual variable shaping the phenomenological quality of NOSCs, based on more extensive empirical evidence, and (2) autonomic dynamics causally contribute to the emergence of NOSCs by destabilizing entrenched predictive models, a more speculative claim. In either case, we propose the ANS as a participant in, not merely an effector of, the mechanisms generating NOSCs, with coordinated sympathovagal co-activation serving as a hallmark of peak NOSCs.
We offer this framework as a hypothesis-generating complement to the strong cortical focus that has dominated NOSCs research in the past decades.

Neural and Experiential Dynamics of High-Ventilation Breathwork Mirror Psychedelic States

Abstract:
High-ventilation breathwork (HVB) is a simple breathing technique that nevertheless frequently triggers experiences resembling psychedelic states. While recent studies have begun to pinpoint physiological and neural changes involved in altered states of consciousness (ASCs) evoked by HVB, the interplay between neural and experiential dynamics throughout an HVB session remains unclear. Here we tracked neural activity (via 64-channel EEG recordings) as well as subjective experience depth and content in 25 experienced HVB practitioners across resting-state recordings interleaved throughout a naturalistic HVB session. We find that neural dynamics evoked by HVB emulate the most robust neural signatures of classical psychedelic states, specifically (1) loosening of temporal structure, including broadband cortical desynchronization, increased signal complexity, and decreased oscillatory power in the Alpha (8 - 13 Hz) range, and (2) reorganization of spatial structure, including a flattening of cortical processing hierarchy. These neural effects directly correlated with participants subjective depth with minute resolution, but were not explained by isolated features of HVB such as music listening or active interoception. Together, these results identify unifying neural features of psychedelic-like ASCs regardless of induction method, demonstrating that cortical states triggered by psychedelics can also be accessed by non-pharmacological routes, and breathwork is a powerful way to do so.